Picture
CHERIAN GEORGE

Published in The Straits Times on 3 December 2011.

With the power to release private thoughts into public space in a heartbeat, the internet has allowed individuals to share ideas like never before. That, unfortunately, includes some thoughts that would have been better kept leashed in the backyards of people’s minds. 

In recent weeks, a series of offensive online messages violated the spirit of mutual respect that is rightly cherished as part of Singapore’s multi-religious identity. 

It is not the first time that hateful online speech has made headlines, and it won’t be the last. Religion matters deeply to most Singaporeans – both those who want their faith to have a greater role in their private and public lives as well as those who believe that some religions have grown too powerful. People will want to speak out on these issues, and the internet provides an undiscriminating forum for all to do so. 

Globalisation complicates the situation: instead of expressing themselves in ways that are sensitive to local norms, people find it convenient to copy-and-paste words and images from other contexts, causing unnecessary offence. 

Contending values

Singapore is not alone in grappling with such issues. Globally, there has been a protracted debate over how best to balance freedom of expression with freedom from discrimination. Hate speech grows out of the former and threatens the latter, which is why it poses a unique challenge for democratic societies – we are dealing with two values, liberty and equality, that are equally precious. 

Freedom of speech and freedom from discrimination are both enshrined in the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights as well as in most democratic constitutions. Different societies tend to attach different weights to them. 

The most extreme form of hate speech – incitement to genocide – poses no legal dilemmas. There is a broad consensus that speech that instigates mass killing can claim no free speech protection. Indeed, international law requires the state to protect minorities from such incitement.

Thus, after the 1994 Rwandan genocide, two directors of the RTLM radio station that had directed violence against Tutsis were sent to jail by the international criminal tribunal. Free speech groups welcomed the action.

What is more contentious internationally is whether governments should intervene long before the final straw breaks the camel’s back. Ethnic violence takes years to develop, gradually escalating from reasonable-sounding racism to the point where people follow orders to kill their neighbours.

American First Amendment jurisprudence is so protective of robust public debate that it refuses to let the government restrict free speech except when this is necessary to prevent imminent physical harm. European courts are not so insistent on a tight causal link between speech and violence. They tend to allow governments to intervene to protect a culture of tolerance and non-discrimination, provided they can show that such restriction serves a legitimate social purpose and is necessary and proportionate. 

For example, one member of the extreme-right British National Party was convicted of a public order offence after displaying in his window a poster with the words, “Islam out of Britain – Protect the British People”, over a picture of the 9/11 attack on the World Trade Center. In 2004, the European Court of Human Rights stated that the British courts’ ruling did not violate the European Convention. The poster’s content was incompatible with the Convention’s values of “tolerance, social peace and non-discrimination”, the European Court said.

In general, though, the European Court has upheld the liberal principle that no group in a democratic society, including any religious community, should expect legal protection from shocking or offensive speech. 

For more than a decade, the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) tried lobbying for just such protection. It sought support from the United Nations General Assembly for “defamation of religion” or blasphemy to be added to the categories under which states could legitimately restrict free speech under international law, along with national security, public order and so on. The idea has intuitive appeal for those who believe that religion is not to be trifled with.

Counter-productive

But banning religious insult is ultimately counter-productive. First, it puts governments in the untenable position of ruling on theological matters. One group’s creed is another’s heresy. Fierce conflicts have tended to occur between different branches of the same religion, over what to outsiders seem like minor doctrinal differences. 

A secular state in a multi-religious society that tries to decide on what constitutes blasphemy would quickly demolish its own legitimacy. Even the OIC changed tack this year, tabling a UN resolution on combating religious intolerance that dropped its previous calls for laws to prohibit defamation of religions. It was passed by the UN Human Rights Council.

Second, those most likely to cry “blasphemy” are the least tolerant members of each religious community. Very quickly, such laws would allow the most dogmatic and extreme spokesmen to set the tone for the rest.

Note that if giving offence is sometimes part of a deliberate campaign of hate, so is taking offence. Often, what looks like spontaneous and visceral reactions to hate speech – angry demonstrations and so on – are orchestrated by activists who spot a political advantage in an outpouring of religious rage.

This has happened next door in Malaysia, where mobs have succeeded in getting the police to stop peaceful inter-faith meetings, claiming that such dialogue has outraged their religious feelings.

Such subjective laws can also be wielded as handy weapons in political conflicts. Consider Thailand’s lèse-majesté law. It was intended to protect the revered monarchy, but since anyone can lodge a complaint, the law has been used by political operatives to hit out at their foes. Almost 500 cases were brought before the lower courts last year.

While Singapore’s political scene is nowhere as contentious as Thailand’s, it is worth noting how swiftly the recent incidents were politicised. Much was made of the political party allegiances of two of the players involved – one linked to the ruling party and another to the opposition. It would be naïve to think that everyone who jumped on the bandwagon to debate these incidents was motivated solely by the need to protect Singapore’s inter-religious harmony. 

At least, though, the recent incidents suggest a vigilant online community. This is reassuring, since public watchfulness is ultimately the best protection against any pollution of Singapore’s culture of tolerance. 

More worrying is the public’s automatic reliance on the police – making police reports has become the standard response to offensive speech. When even cyberspace – normally the last place you would expect to see calls for strong government – is full of postings asking the police to investigate, you have to wonder if Singaporeans are over-dependent on the authorities for maintaining social peace. 

It is reminiscent of one of the more pathetic sights in professional football: players surrounding the referee after an opponent has committed a foul, imploring him to wave the red card. It is a practice that does nothing to cultivate a spirit of sportsmanship.

After last year’s case of the Christian pastor who insulted Taoist and Buddhist beliefs, the government was asked in Parliament to give “a stronger and clearer signal for every breach”. The Home Affairs Minister at the time, Mr K. Shanmugam, demurred, noting that disagreements should be “mediated or resolved on the ground through common sense, and moral suasion using the collective efforts of the community, grassroots and religious leaders”.

Singaporeans’ weak civic responses and an over-reliance on the law may be an unintended consequence of successful inculcation of a key government doctrine: that only a strong state can deal with the visceral pulls and permanent fault lines of race and religion. Distrusting citizens’ ability to talk through differences, some Singaporeans seem trigger-happy in their zeal to police the frontiers of religious harmony. 

Many posts that criticise a religion are probably not worth bothering about, especially if they come from random individuals with no standing in the community. The need for whistle-blowing increases in proportion with the speaker’s influence, with community leaders and public officials requiring the most careful scrutiny.

If the editor of a website or the head of an organisation engages in insensitive speech, there are many ways to enforce societal norms without resorting to the law. One could simply publicise the breach or organise a boycott until the speaker grovels in contrition – or explains his pure motives to the aggrieved party’s satisfaction.

Regardless of how the law responds, Singaporeans can expect to see more instances of religiously offensive speech online. We should think of more creative ways to respond than to rush to the referee, flapping our imaginary red cards.

 


Comments

31/01/2014 02:08

Bookmarked your blog, it's awsome

Reply
11/02/2014 18:33

Have you ever considered writing an ebook or guest authoring on other blogs? I have a blog based on the same subjects you discuss and would really like to have you share some stories/information. I know my visitors would appreciate your work. If you are even remotely interested, feel free to send me an e-mail.

Reply
22/02/2014 13:10

One thing I would really like to say is always that before buying more personal computer memory, look at the machine in to which it is installed. In case the machine is usually running Windows XP, for instance, the particular memory threshold is 3.25GB. Using in excess of this would easily constitute any waste. Make sure one's motherboard can handle the particular upgrade quantity, as well. Good blog post.

Reply
03/03/2014 00:43

It is not the first time that hateful online speech has made headlines, and it won’t be the last. Religion matters deeply to most Singaporeans

Reply
03/03/2014 09:16

thank's you for great post about spin

Reply
03/03/2014 11:12

Wow, Good post. Thanks for share

Reply
03/03/2014 16:18

i like this post,

Reply
03/03/2014 17:05

thanx man.. http://goo.gl/bJV84q

Reply
03/03/2014 17:42

very useful for information about the red card :)

Reply
03/03/2014 17:43

best articel for me

Reply

the possiblities are endless. If you don't have a location in mind, no worries, we know a ton of cool places so we can help you make up your mind. That's what we're here for!

<a href="http://aura-glow.net/aura-glow-cream-pemutih-wajah-dan-perawatan-wajah.html">aura glow</a>

<a href="http://aura-glow.net/perawatan-wajah-aura-glow-magic-cream.html">aura glow</a>

Reply
03/03/2014 18:28

Hey, just looking around some blogs, seems a pretty nice platform you are using. I'm currently using Wordpress for a few of my sites but looking to change one of them over to a platform similar to yours as a trial run. Anything in particular you would recommend about it? http://iblogracing.blogspot.com

Reply
03/03/2014 23:33

wow, that a big help, thanks for sharing ^^
<a href="http://wormtalecloth.com/">Men and Women Fashion Store</a>

Reply
04/03/2014 00:21

Sangat bermanfaat. Lets see our blog here:
<a href='http://www.initips.com/2013/09/tips-move-on-atau-melupakan-seseorang.html'>Tips Move On</a>
<a href='http://www.100hdwallpaper.com'>100% HD Wallpaper</a>
<a href='http://berbagi-10.blogspot.com/2014/02/10-gunung-paling-berbahaya-di-dunia.html'>Top 10 Indo</a>

Reply
04/03/2014 02:43

wonderful I love reading and I'm glad that I found your site. Thank you for always providing us a new book that we can read online. I feel a lot after reading your blog, I have read all that, so at this time me also commenting here
<a href='http://wartasaranamedia.com/'>health information</a>

Reply
04/03/2014 10:30

wonderful I love reading and I'm glad that I found your site.

Reply
04/03/2014 13:07

Very good article. I really like your writing style. I wait for your next post. If anyone needs, I have information about <a href="http://contohsuratformal.com">contoh surat</a>

Reply
04/03/2014 16:04

Finally, an issue that I am passionate about. I have looked for information of this caliber for the last several hours.

Reply
04/03/2014 16:05

These facts are amazing. I was searching before last 5 weeks and i dint get the perfect answer.

Reply
04/03/2014 17:52

beli jam tangan yuk http://www.jamtangan-kwsuper.blogspot.com hehehe

Reply
04/03/2014 23:20

Very informative article, thanks for share

Reply
04/03/2014 23:21

Great article, thanks

Reply
04/03/2014 23:22

Good Post.. thanks for share

Reply
05/03/2014 01:24

Nice post

Reply
05/03/2014 01:31

i agree with you it should

Reply
05/03/2014 02:22

Good argument (y)

Reply
05/03/2014 03:40

Thank you, I possess simply already been searching for <a href="http://saranblog.net/superwash-laundry-bisnis-franchise-waralaba-murah-di-indonesia/">Superwash Laundry Bisnis Franchise Waralaba Murah di Indonesia </a> info around this particular subject matter for a long time plus you own the very best There really is away up to now. However exactly what regarding the main point here? Are you currently good regarding the resource?

Reply
05/03/2014 10:17

Thank you very much, very useful article, go back http://photoshopku.net/

Reply
05/03/2014 11:01

very useful <a href="http://tophairstyler.com">Best Hairstyler</a>

Reply
05/03/2014 17:13

Thanks for the post, it's useful to learn about. Hmmmm.... Always stay tuned foy your updates. :D

www.mesinbalap.com
www.newcarslineup.com

Reply
Kunci Jawaban Tebak gambar
05/03/2014 18:20

Thanks for the post, it's useful to learn about http://sshgratiz.blogspot.com/2014/02/kunci-jawaban-lengkap-tebak-gambar.html

Reply
05/03/2014 18:21

nice post i like it

Reply
05/03/2014 19:00

hmm,,, its interesting article, , ,

Reply
05/03/2014 19:09

good article, thx for sharing, , ,

Reply
05/03/2014 19:32

SUKABET.COM AGEN BOLA TERPERCAYA UNTUK PIALA DUNIA 2014

http://risfani.blogdetik.com/2014/02/15/sukabetcom-agen-bola-terpercaya-untuk-piala-dunia-2014/

Reply
05/03/2014 20:09

very nice article..
iam like search you article

http://jersey-bola.co/jersey-world-cup-2014

Reply
05/03/2014 23:17

Thanks

Reply
05/03/2014 23:17

Nice Info

Reply
sportblazer
05/03/2014 23:38

nice article
http://sportblazers.blogspot.com/

Reply
05/03/2014 23:51

Very informative article its improve my global information!
Many thank to your article!

Reply
06/03/2014 08:39

ArenaSepatu.com Toko Sepatu Olahraga Online

Reply
06/03/2014 12:11

Thank you for your information.

Reply
06/03/2014 13:28

Many thank to your article!


<a href="http://yustishop.com/5-lingerie" rel="dofollow" target="blank">Lingerie Murah</a>

Reply
06/03/2014 15:17

amazing article, I think, a useful speech for most listeners keil

Reply
06/03/2014 15:19

red card as to what is meant?

Reply
06/03/2014 15:21

I rarely hear the speech, I do not like it

Reply
06/03/2014 16:16

nice post!

Reply
06/03/2014 18:36

religious tolerance is necessary for the integrity of a nation, the government should be able to keep it.

Reply
06/03/2014 18:50

nice articles bro, thanks and keep posting

Reply
06/03/2014 19:51

nice post dude!

Reply
06/03/2014 19:52

keep posting !

Reply
06/03/2014 21:14

Thanks for sharing dude

<a href="http://www.murahbaru.com/hb-whitening-lotion-pemutih-kulit-alami-terbaik.html" target="_blank">HB Whitening Lotion Pemutih Kulit Alami Harga Murah</a>

<a href="http://www.murahbaru.com" target="_blank">Toko online kosmetik asli murah</a>

<a href="http://www.murahbaru.co.id" target="_blank">toko Agen Grosir kosmetik online</a>

Reply
07/03/2014 02:56

this very beautiful on this comments thank for admin thanks you hatespin

Reply
07/03/2014 03:58

Nice post, althoug lil bit long :)

Reply

tq nice post, tanks

Reply
07/03/2014 12:53

good article and keep posting broo

Reply
07/03/2014 17:16

This is an article about extraordinary, and I really enjoyed it. if you want to get inspiration about interior design a lot of other references.

Reply
07/03/2014 18:24

I just added this feed to my favorites. I like reading your posts. Thank you!

Reply
07/03/2014 23:21

Great post, i like reading your blogs because can inspire me ...thx

Reply
08/03/2014 00:06

wow great thing, i like it

Reply
08/03/2014 09:41

Thanks for shareng, nice blog, I like it.

Please visit back my online store <a href="http://www.murahbaru.com/toko-agen-grosir-madu-penyubur-kandungan-al-mabruroh-obat-mandul.html" target="_blank">Jual madu penyubur kandungan al mabruroh</a> and <a href="http://www.murahbaru.com/" target="_blank">murahbaru.com</a> and also <a href="http://www.murahbaru.co.id" target="_blank">murahbaru.co.id</a>

Reply
08/03/2014 11:42

JUAL BEDAK TABUR SKIN 79 HARGA MURAH, Menghilangkan Komedo Dengan Cepat. SKIN79 ALL DAY SUN LOOSE POWDER mengandung SPF30 PA++ yang bisa memberikan perlindungan menyeluruh untuk kulit wajah dari radikal bebas dan paparan sinar UV.

Bedak Tabur Skin 79 juga mampu mengontrol minyak berlebih sehingga efektif mencegah timbulnya komedo. Bukan hanya itu saja, Bedak tabur Skin 79 juga mengandung Diamond powder dan Blooming Jewel Complex ekstrak yang ampuh mencerahkan kulit wajah Anda.

Kelebihan lainnya adalah tekstur dari bedak ini yang sangat lembut dan silky sehingga ringan dan nyaman saat digunakan.

Isi 13 gram

Cara Memesan Bedak Tabur Skin 79

Untuk memudahkan pemesanan, silahkan hubungi SMS/Whatsapp/line/kakaotalk: 085691320074 atau add PIN BB; 28468EE8 atau di website murahbaru.com

Reply
08/03/2014 12:11

Hi nice blog, thanks for posting. do not forget to visit back my blog at Jual Bedak Tabur Skin 79 asli at <a href="http://www.murahbaru.com/bedak-tabur-skin-79-menghilangkan-komedo-dengan-cepat.html">murahbaru.com</a> and <a href="http://www.murahbaru.com/bedak-tabur-skin-79-menghilangkan-komedo-dengan-cepat.html">murahbaru.co.id</a>

Reply

Thank you for nice share

Reply

Good article and very helpfull for us

Reply
08/03/2014 22:04

Thank you for great blog. This blog content very informative for me and now i have already bookmark for visit again to fine more best article form this blog. Thank you

Reply
10/03/2014 03:02

hahaha... nice share, if you don't wanna your article to be spinned...don't post to the internet, that was the simple way

Reply
10/03/2014 17:42

http://saharareporters.com/gallery/photonews-nema-reaches-source-pipeline-fire-lagos?nocache=1#comment-675492

Reply
10/03/2014 17:47

Thanks a lot for your posting, come on visit back my blog at Cream Sari Pemutih Wajah at <a href="http://www.murahbaru.com/cream-sari-pemutih-wajah-ber-bpom-aman-cepat-alami.html">www.murahbaru.com</a> and also <a href="http://www.murahbaru.co.id/">www.murahbaru.co.id</a>

Reply
10/03/2014 17:49

Thanks a lot for your posting, come on visit back my blog at Cream Sari Pemutih Wajah at www.murahbaru.com and also www.murahbaru.co.id

Reply
11/03/2014 01:21

Any way I'll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon.

Reply
11/03/2014 05:55

mantap om

Reply
11/03/2014 18:07

wonderful I love reading and I'm glad that I found your site. Thank you for always providing us - See more at: http://hatespin.weebly.com/1/post/2011/12/why-hate-speech-doesnt-always-require-the-red-card.html#sthash.6kMQ4Vv9.dpuf

Reply
12/03/2014 05:39

Thanks a lot for your posting.. It's relly help me

Reply
12/03/2014 05:41

I am really enjoying reading your well written articles. I think you spend numerous effort and time updating your blog.

Reply
12/03/2014 05:46

I discovered your blog site on google and check a few of your early posts. Continue to keep up the very good operate.

Reply
13/03/2014 14:07

I simply wished to thank you very much yet again.

Reply
13/03/2014 14:09

Nice info, i enjoyed your site,
<a href="http://canoncameraa.blogspot.com/" rel="nofollow">harga
terbaru kamera</a>

Reply
14/03/2014 06:04

I just wish to give an enormous thumbs up for the nice info you've got right here on this post

Reply
15/03/2014 00:18

After looking over a handful of the blog posts on your blog, I seriously appreciate your way of blogging.

I bookmarked it to my bookmark webpage list and will be checking back in the near future.

Please visit my website as well and let me know your opinion.
<a href="http://www.futurenewcarrelease.com/2015-toyota-tacoma-redesign-and-price.html" target="_blank">Future Car Release 2014 - 2014</a>

Reply
17/03/2014 17:19

I am really enjoying reading your well written articles. It looks like you spend a lot of effort and time on your blog. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles.

Reply
17/03/2014 17:26

If some one needs to be updated with hottest technologies then he must be pay a quick visit this web page and be up to date everyday.

Reply
17/03/2014 17:28

Great blog! I really love how it is easy on my eyes and the information are well written. I am wondering how I might be notified whenever a new post has been made. I have subscribed to your rss feed which really should do the trick! Have a nice day!

Reply
17/03/2014 17:28

This web site is really a walk-through for all of the info you wanted about this and didn’t know who to ask. Glimpse here, and you’ll definitely discover it….

Reply
17/03/2014 19:20

nice article, very educated. keep posting

Reply
18/03/2014 17:07

Nice observation and analyze from you, this is the nice posting that i've reading today. One of the best posting at this hatespin.weebly.com are this post. I don't understand too much about the counter-productive point that you mentioned above. Hope you will explained it for me later. :)

Reply
18/03/2014 21:27

Wow I need to to thank you for ones time for this particularly fantastic read!! <a href="http://www.duniasekolah.com/">Dunia Sekolah</a> and <a href="http://www.duniasekolah.com/">Dunia Pendidikan </a> :)

Reply
18/03/2014 21:28

Hello, i am glad to read the whole content of this blog and am very excited and happy to say that the webmaster has done a very good job here to put all the information content and information at one place

Reply
18/03/2014 21:29

I bookmarked it to my bookmark webpage list and will be checking back in the near
future.

Reply
18/03/2014 21:30

These are really brilliant plans in concerning blogging. You have touched some pleasant focuses here. Any path keep up composing.

Reply
19/03/2014 00:21

Yes I'm hate too, btw this is good blog

Reply

Blogwalking...

Please visits my link

Reply

it's really nice and meanful. it's really cool blog. Linking is very useful thing.you have really helped lots of people who visit blog and provide them usefull information.

Reply
22/03/2014 06:51

Very good article. I really like your writing style. I wait for your next post. If anyone needs,

Reply
22/03/2014 22:46

Hrmm that was weird, my comment got eaten. Anyway I wanted to say that it's nice to know that someone else also mentioned this as I had trouble finding the same info elsewhere. This was the first place that told me the answer. Thanks.

Reply
22/03/2014 22:51

I must admit that this is one great insight. It surely gives a company the opportunity to get in on the ground floor and really take part in creating something special and tailored to their needs.

Reply
22/03/2014 22:52

Hey, just looking around some blogs, seems a pretty nice platform you are using. I'm currently using Wordpress for a few of my sites but looking to change one of them over to a platform similar to yours as a trial run. Anything in particular you would recommend about it?

Reply
22/03/2014 22:54


This is a really good read for me, Must admit that you are one of the best bloggers I ever saw.Thanks for posting this informative article.

Reply
22/03/2014 23:17

i like this page, i know it form a forum

Reply
23/03/2014 08:25

This is a really good read for me

Reply

It surely gives a company the opportunity to get in on the ground floor and really take part in creating something - I must admit that this is one great insight.

Reply
26/03/2014 11:39

it's really nice and meanful. it's really cool blog. Linking is very useful thing.you have really helped lots of people who visit blog and provide them usefull information.

Reply

Pretty good post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I'll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon.
<a href="http://jimmyhendrix.me/unit-link-terbaik-di-indonesia/unit-link-terbaik-di-indonesia-commonwealth-life-investra-link/" title="Unit Link Terbaik Di Indonesia Commonwealth Life Investra Link">Unit Link Terbaik Di Indonesia Commonwealth Life Investra Link</a>

Reply
28/03/2014 06:29

amazing, very good article, very useful for readers who need

Reply

Asustek Computer Inc., or that we are familiar with the brand ASUS is a manufacturer of notebook or laptop is the best in the world.

Reply
04/04/2014 11:31

it's really nice and meanful. it's really cool blog. Linking is very
useful thing.you have really helped lots of people who

Reply
11/04/2014 22:21

thank you for the information. This is a very informative web

Reply
16/04/2014 12:14

such a greta post here bit.ly/1iorqsf

Reply
16/04/2014 17:10

y nice and meanful. it's really cool blog. Linking is very useful thing.you have really helped lots of people who

Reply
16/04/2014 17:11

eanful. it's really cool blog. Linking is very useful thing.you have really helped lots of people who visit blog and provide them usefull information

Reply



Leave a Reply